This case study is about “The Daily Grind,” a popular independent coffee shop in Atlanta’s Virginia-Highland, and what we did with their Q3 2026 digital strategy. They had a “Best of Atlanta” award, but their ads weren’t really using it. The whole campaign was a test: could we turn that community award into real, measurable ROI by plastering it all over their local business ads?
Key Takeaways
- Putting the “Best of Atlanta” award in the ad creative jumped click-through rates by 45% over their old ads.
- We built custom affinity audiences targeting people who went to local events or other coffee shops, and it dropped our cost per lead by 30%.
- The A/B tests were clear: ad copy saying “Voted #1 Coffee Shop” beat headlines that just talked about benefits.
- We spent 25% of the budget on geofencing ads around their competitors, which directly led to an 18% bump in foot traffic during the campaign.
- Surveys after the campaign showed a 15% jump in brand trust for new customers who’d seen the ads with the award.
Campaign Overview: The Daily Grind’s Award-Winning Strategy
The Daily Grind sits right near North Highland Avenue NE and Amsterdam Avenue NE, and for three years running, they’d won “Best Coffee Shop” in local polls. The problem was, this wasn’t translating into their digital ad performance, which was flat by early 2026. Conversions were okay, but not great. So for Q3 2026, the mission was to take that community trust they’d earned and use it to get more new customers in the door and buying their specialty beans online. Our bet was that showing off the award in ads would hit harder than another picture of a latte.
We ran the campaign for 12 weeks, starting July 1st and wrapping on September 23rd, 2026, with a total budget of $9,000. That money was mostly spent on Google Local Services Ads, Meta (so, Facebook and Instagram), and Yelp Ads. For KPIs, we were watching the usual suspects: Cost Per Lead (CPL), Return on Ad Spend (ROAS), and Click-Through Rate (CTR), but we were also tracking impressions and, most importantly, conversions, which we defined as new loyalty program sign-ups for in-store visits and direct online bean sales.
| Metric | Pre-Campaign Baseline (Q2 2026) | Campaign Result (Q3 2026) | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Budget | $7,500 | $9,000 | +20% |
| Impressions | 285,000 | 410,000 | +43.8% |
| CTR (Average) | 1.8% | 2.6% | +44.4% |
| Conversions (New Customers) | 320 | 580 | +81.3% |
| Cost Per Conversion | $23.44 | $15.52 | -33.8% |
| ROAS | 2.8x | 4.1x | +46.4% |
Strategy and Targeting: Pinpointing the Local Audience
We hit this from a few different angles, using the “Best of Atlanta” award differently on each platform. On Google Local Services Ads, it was all about owning searches like “coffee shop Virginia-Highland” and “best coffee Atlanta.” This meant a full optimization of their Google Business Profile, packing it with good photos of the actual award plaque and making sure we highlighted reviews that talked about their spot in the community.
Over on Meta Ads Manager for Facebook and Instagram, we got pretty specific with the targeting. We started by uploading their customer list as a CSV to build 1% and 2% lookalike audiences within a 5-mile radius. Then we layered on interest targeting for people following “Atlanta food blogs,” “local Atlanta events,” or who were in groups like “Virginia-Highland Neighbors.” The real key here, though, was a custom affinity audience we built to go after people who visited the pages of their direct competitors or interacted with businesses near Ponce City Market. This let us put an ad right in front of someone who was already looking for a great local coffee or food spot.
Yelp Ads were mostly a reputation and validation play. We used them to show off the award status right in the search results for coffee and cafes. We made sure their Yelp business page had the award badge front and center and used the call-to-action buttons to drive calls and website traffic.
Creative Approach: Award-Winning Visuals and Messaging
Our whole creative approach was to put the award front and center. For the Meta ads, we ran three main types of creative:
- Image Ad (Static): A high-res photo of a barista holding the “Best of Atlanta” plaque, with the shop buzzing in the background. The text overlay was simple: “Voted #1 Coffee Shop in Atlanta!”
- Video Ad (15-second): A quick-cut video showing the shop’s vibe, coffee being made, happy people, and then a final zoom-in on the award plaque. The voiceover was, “Your neighborhood’s favorite, officially recognized as Atlanta’s best.”
- Carousel Ad: This was a sequence showing off pastries, latte art, and their seating area, with the very last card being a hero shot of the award and a call to action: “Experience Atlanta’s Top-Rated Coffee.”
On Google Local Services Ads, we baked the award right into the business description and headline, and we used ad extensions to pull in customer testimonials that talked about the quality. Across the board, we used phrases like “Award-Winning Coffee,” “Voted Best in Atlanta,” and “Community’s Choice.” We didn’t bother with discounts, just the endorsement. It felt more authentic than an aggressive sales pitch, which is what wins in a local market.
What Worked: The Power of Social Proof
What worked? Plain and simple, it was social proof. The click-through rate on ads that showed the award just blew the old ones out of the water. On Meta, for example, that static image of the barista holding the plaque hit a 3.1% CTR, a huge jump from the 1.9% they were getting with their old product-focused ads. Because more people were clicking, the Cost Per Click (CPC) dropped from $1.15 in Q2 all the way down to $0.78.
The geofencing we did around their competitors was money well spent. We drew a tight 0.2-mile radius around places like Inman Perk Coffee and Proof Coffee House and served ads to anyone detected inside it. The idea was to catch people right when they were thinking about coffee and hit them with a better, award-winning option. It worked. That specific audience converted at 4.2%, which tells you people are willing to switch if you give them a good reason.
And we can’t forget Yelp Ads. They didn’t get a ton of impressions, but the leads they sent were solid. We saw the average call duration from Yelp leads go up by 15%, which usually means the caller is more qualified and ready to buy or visit. People on Yelp are actively looking for a place to go, so having that award visible there really sealed the deal for a lot of them. You have to be on the platforms where people are already searching.
What Didn’t Work and Optimization Steps
Of course, not everything worked perfectly. Our first attempt included a 60-second video about the shop’s history. It bombed. People were dropping off after 10 seconds, and the CTR was a miserable 0.8%. It was a fast lesson that for local ads aimed at people on their phones, you need to be quick and get to the point. We killed that ad and moved its budget over to the 15-second video and the static images that were actually working.
We also ran into a frequency issue. People on Instagram started complaining in the comments that they were seeing the same award ad over and over. We had set the cap at 3 impressions per user per week, but that was clearly too high for some audiences and was starting to generate negative feedback. We cut the frequency cap in half to 1.5 impressions per user per week on Meta, especially for the lookalike audiences. This stopped the complaints and kept the brand perception positive without a noticeable hit to our reach.
Our initial Google Ads keyword bidding strategy was also too wide. We were bidding on “best coffee” and getting clicks from way outside their service area, past Midtown Atlanta. We tightened things up by adding negative keywords like “best coffee recipes” and “coffee beans wholesale” and put more money on specific, local keywords like “best coffee Virginia-Highland” or “coffee shop near Piedmont Park.” That simple cleanup work cut down on wasted spend and dropped our Google Ads cost per conversion by another 12% during the second half of the campaign.
Data and Insights: Quantifying Success
The numbers at the end of the campaign tell the story. Our overall Cost Per Conversion fell from $23.44 to just $15.52, which is a 33.8% improvement. That efficiency came directly from the higher CTRs and better conversion rates we got by focusing on the award. The ROAS jumped from 2.8x to a very healthy 4.1x. In plain English, for every $1 The Daily Grind spent on these ads, they made back $4.10 in revenue from new customers.
We sent out a survey to new loyalty program members after the campaign, and the feedback confirmed our theory. About 60% of them said an ad was the main reason they came in. And of that group, a full 75% specifically remembered seeing the “Best of Atlanta” award in the ad. This is great qualitative feedback that shows the award wasn’t just background noise. It was a major trust signal that actually got people in the door.
We also saw some interesting splits by age group and platform. The video ads on Instagram really hit with the 25-34 crowd, who were clicking through to buy beans online. Meanwhile, Facebook static images worked better for the 35-54 demographic, who seemed more interested in in-store visits. It just goes to show you have to tailor your creative and platform choice to who you’re trying to reach, even when you’re just advertising locally. Knowing your social media marketing basics is key here.
Conclusion
The takeaway here is that using a community award in your local ads is a hard-nosed, measurable strategy that gets results. The Daily Grind’s campaign showed that putting their local award front and center built trust, lowered their cost to get a new customer, and drove real growth. If you’ve earned community endorsements, show them off. They’re one of the best sales tools you have. For more on this, check out how data-driven ads can boost ROAS.
Where can a small business find local awards?
Start by looking at local city magazines, community websites, and newspapers that run “Best Of” reader polls or have editor’s choice awards. Your local Chamber of Commerce is another good source, as they often promote member wins. Talk to your neighborhood associations too. And don’t forget to look for industry-specific awards in your area, like “Best Bakery” or “Top Auto Repair Shop.”
What’s the best way to show an award in an ad?
You need to show it and say it. Use high-quality photos or video shots of the actual plaque or certificate. In your ad copy, use direct phrases like “Award-Winning,” “Voted Best,” or “Community’s Choice.” The key is to make the award easy to see, but don’t let it completely take over the ad. It should support your product or service, not replace it.
Can I use the same award ad on Facebook and Instagram?
No, you shouldn’t. Keep the message about the award the same, but tailor the ad’s format for each platform. A short, punchy video is great for Instagram Reels or Stories, but a strong static image with a great headline might do better in a Facebook feed or on the Google Display Network. You have to build the ad for how people use that specific platform.
How do I know if using the award in my ads is actually working?
You measure it. Look at your CTR, CPC, Conversion Rate, and ROAS and compare the new award-focused campaign numbers to your old baseline. The best way to be sure is to run an A/B test, pitting a creative with the award against one without it. You can also use post-purchase surveys to ask new customers what got them in the door. It’s a great source of qualitative feedback.
Can I show off my award too much?
Absolutely. If people see the same ad over and over, they’ll get tired of it (ad fatigue), or they might think you’re coasting on an old win. Don’t make the award the only thing you talk about. Mix in messages about your products, your service, and what makes you great. Also, make sure the award is from a source people actually respect. Keep an eye on your ad frequency and comments to make sure you’re not annoying people.